Skip to content

Design process

Logo refresh or redesign? Find the problem before changing the mark

“It needs to feel more modern” is a conversation starter, not a design brief. Work out what is failing before deciding how much to change.

The short answer

Choose the smallest scope that solves the documented problem. A damaged file needs repair; an awkward mark may need refinement; inconsistent applications may need a stronger system. A changed audience or positioning can justify a wider redesign.

1. Replace “outdated” with an observable problem

Ask the client to show where the identity causes trouble. Perhaps the name disappears in a mobile header, the symbol is confused with another business, or every presentation looks unrelated. These are different problems. A mood word such as “premium” will not tell you which one to solve.

Collect the current artwork and a few recent applications before opening a fresh artboard. Write one sentence describing the failure and who experiences it. “The small lettering is unreadable on our product label” gives the project a useful target. “We are bored with blue” mostly gives it a colour.

2. Separate four possible scopes

Use these four working categories to discuss the job. They are a practical framework, not a universal industry standard. More than one may apply, but naming them helps avoid selling a full rebrand when the client needs a usable file.

  • Asset repair: reconstruct damaged or incomplete artwork without intentionally changing the design.
  • Logo refinement: improve a mark’s drawing, spacing or practical performance while keeping its established idea.
  • Identity-system refresh: improve typography, imagery, colour roles and layouts around a logo that can remain.
  • Strategic redesign: reconsider the visual direction because the business, audience or positioning has materially changed.

Different problems, different scopes

  1. Repair

    The file is unusable

    Restore the approved artwork

  2. Refine

    The mark struggles in use

    Improve the existing design

  3. Refresh

    Applications feel disconnected

    Strengthen the identity system

  4. Redesign

    The direction no longer fits

    Revisit the strategic brief

An original decision framework. The categories can overlap; they are not a mandatory ladder of increasingly expensive work.

3. Inspect applications, not just a large logo

Choose five relevant touchpoints from the client’s actual work. A café might need a storefront, cup, menu, social avatar and delivery listing. A software company will have a different set. Check each at its intended size and on its real background; a beautiful giant mockup can hide a tiny practical problem.

Separate problems caused by the mark from problems caused by poor use. In Pentagram’s Westinghouse project, the established logo stayed while typography and other identity elements developed around it. That historical example shows why changing the surrounding system deserves consideration before replacing the symbol.

Further reading: Pentagram: the Westinghouse identity project · Westinghouse: its account of the 2023 refresh

4. Turn the audit into a small worksheet

Use four columns: observed problem, evidence, proposed change and validation. Keep the evidence concrete: an actual-size screenshot, a production sample or a recurring error in client materials. These observations do not automatically prove why customers buy or leave.

Alder is a fictional café used here to illustrate the method. Its logo might be perfectly usable on a sign but fail on a small label. That does not mean the entire identity is broken.

  • Problem: small lettering closes up on the label. Evidence: a printed sample at the intended size.
  • Change: test more open letterforms or a compact approved version. Validation: print the same label again.
  • Problem: every menu uses a different typeface. Change: define a typography system before redrawing the logo.

Alder: a fictional audit

  1. Observed problem
    Small lettering closes up
    Evidence
    Actual-size printed label
    Proposed change
    Open letterforms or use a compact version
    Validation
    Print and inspect the revised label
  2. Observed problem
    Menus look unrelated
    Evidence
    Three current menu layouts
    Proposed change
    Define shared typography and layout rules
    Validation
    Apply the rules to all three menus
Alder is an invented teaching example, not a client case or a measured result.

5. Decide what should remain recognizable

List the features you intend to retain: the name, silhouette, distinctive letterform, colour relationship or another established cue. Ask why each matters. Familiarity within the design team is not the same as recognition among customers, so use available research and real customer observations where possible.

In her PRINT interview, Jessica Hische describes refresh work that improves an existing logo’s usefulness. Treat refinement as a purposeful design task, not a polite word for making everything slightly different.

Further reading: PRINT: Jessica Hische on logo refreshes

6. Present changes under comparable conditions

Show the current and proposed work at matching sizes, on matching backgrounds and in the same applications. Do not give the old logo a gloomy slide and the new one a beautiful campaign. That proves you can art-direct a presentation, not that you solved the brief.

For Alder, compare the current label with the refined label and explain exactly what changed. If the main problem was inconsistent menus, show the new system working across several menus. Ask reviewers whether the documented problem is resolved, rather than which image they simply prefer.

7. Agree the scope, then plan the rollout

Finish with a short written agreement: what stays, what changes, which applications must work and how the result will be checked. Include the replacement list for old files and templates. Even a modest refresh becomes confusing when the previous and current versions circulate without labels.

Once the direction is approved, move into production checks and an organized handoff. LogoPack can help prepare and organize logo exports; it does not decide whether a business needs a new identity. Keep the strategic decision with the people and evidence that informed the brief.

PUT IT INTO PRACTICE

Ready to prepare your pack?

Check the final artwork before preparing the handoff.

logopack.app turns existing SVG artwork into an organized logo package. Preview your files, choose the available export options and check the result before handing it over. Exporting your own logo or icon files requires Pro.

Start with the logo pack generator, explore the sample ZIP, or compare the current plans.

Open generator
← All guidesSuggest a correction